All panels are equal, but some panels are more equal than others

Posted on 28th May 2012 by Youth

Tatenda Musesengwa

Panel quality is a major issue in the market research industry and rightly so. Debates around data quality, panellist engagement and the impact of downward price pressures have led some to argue that the industry’s future is bleak and may even be under existential threat. Running the Panel Services team here at YouthSight, I’m fairly confident that we (and the best providers) have a great future because we fulfill a vital role (fast, accurate, verified sampling with a willing, pre-identified audience). But I’m also keen on the (inevitable) shakeout happening as soon as possible. It’s vital that the differences between the best and worst suppliers becomes far clearer. If you agree, please read on!

Ron Sellars summarises the worst practices in the industry brilliantly in his Dirty Little Secrets series. He exposes the shameful practices of some suppliers and their effects on respondent behaviour. Barraging panelists with survey invites… no quality controls… disastrously long surveys… poor questionnaire design… dreadful incentive schemes… It’s all there. But as compelling and relevant (and damning) as his evidence is, it simply doesn’t apply to all companies in the access panel industry. I know, because it doesn’t apply to us! We’ve always worked to a simple philosophy. It can be summed up in a single word: respect. And it can be broken out into our equally simple four part mantra:

1) We don’t rip off our community of panelists
2) It’s about more than cash
3) We don’t want bad panelists
4) We know our clients recognize quality!

In our experience, if you treat people well and do the simple things properly, most of the problems that Sellars sets out simply don’t occur. To clarify what makes our approach different I have put together a short video (and an accompanying brochure) to explain (thanks to Ben and Lucy for helping with the vid!) Please take a look and tell me what you think. I’d like to use this as an opportunity to start a conversation with people interested in the access panel industry, so please leave a comment below, on Twitter or contact me directly via email and let me know your thoughts on the access panel industry, distinctiveness and quality.

Roll the video!

Related Posts

CASE Europe Conference 2015...

28th August 2015
CASE 2015 Thumbnail

YouthSight will be sponsoring, speaking and exhibiting at the CASE Europe Annual Conference September 1st – 4th at the Manchester Ce...

POSTED INEvents, News

ARE GUILDHE STUDENTS DIFFERENT WHEN SELECTING UNIVERISTIES?...

25th August 2015
GuildHe Logo thumbnail

In a recent presentation at GuildHE (the body representing 27 UK universities, university colleges and specialist colleges) James MacGregor,...

POSTED INEvents, News, Press

THE YOUTH AUDIENCE FOR INDEPENDENT MUSIC...

25th August 2015
JH theHub Thumbnail

The Hub is an organisation set up to help promote independent music.  They invited Josephine Hansom, our Director of Youth Research to spea...

POSTED INEvents, News

HEPI/HEA Student Academic Experience Survey 2015...

23rd June 2015

The Higher Education Policy Institute and the Higher Education Academy launched results of the 2015 Student Academic Experience Survey on Th...

POSTED INNews, Press

YouthSight in the news – BBC – Students doubt uni course value...

23rd June 2015

The BBC featured results from the Higher Education Policy Institute (HEPI) and the Higher Education Academy’s (HEA) recent survey, the 201...

POSTED INNews, Press

GIVING HIGHER EDUCATION THE DIGITAL EDGE...

1st June 2015
Capture22-254x192

YouthSight’s Director of HE Research, James MacGregor, was invited to speak at Ve Interactive’s one day conference; “Giving Higher Edu...

POSTED INEvents, News

YouthSight in the news – The Prospect – Lib Dem vote plummets...

19th March 2015

YouthSight's February 2015 student polling data has been recently featured in The Prospect. In a recent article discussing the relevancy of...

YouthSight in the news – UK Polling Report – Our data featured...

19th March 2015

YouthSight's February 2015 student polling data has been recently featured in The UK Polling Report. In a recent article discussing the mos...