Fieldwork Tips: Is the traditional survey dead? [Clue: no]

Posted on 15th November 2011 by Youth

By Ben Marks, Managing Director, OpinionPanel

The traditional survey is dead.  We’ve reached ‘peak panel’…  That’s what orthodoxy suggests and it’s the contention behind many presentations at research conferences and discussion in market research magazines and journals.  But before we all jump ship, let’s reflect on the last five years and why ‘online quant’ and the panel industry has moved from ‘heroes to zeros’ (in some peoples’ books, anyway).

Well, the web has clearly come of age; people now handle vastly more information online, but no fundamental changes to human nature have occurred.  That should all be grist to the mill for managers of online panels.  Yet some in our industry frequently contend that the ‘asking of questions’ is passé.

That’s clearly nonsense.  Listening to conversations on social media can only take you so far.  Often you just need to ask questions (normally to targeted or representative samples).

Asking is not the problem.  But there are real problems in our industry.  However, many of the problems lie squarely with researchers and the panel industry.  NOT with respondents.  The survey is not dead and it shouldn’t even be ‘losing its flavour’; but it has, over the last few years, been served up very poorly by many panel companies.

Respondents are rational and as such they will sometimes provide stupid answers, but normally to stupid questions.  They will act like naughty monkeys, but normally when they’re paid peanuts.  The real challenge is for the industry to face its responsibilities rather than give up ‘asking’.  This means we need to engage with participants with maturity and respect.  And to stop referring to people as ‘sample’.

We need to accept that we are generally now appealing to respondents’ extrinsic motivation, so have to incentivise accordingly.  We need to make surveys faster and more interesting so that probably means formally abandoning the ‘answer grid’, understanding the impact and consequences of screeners, integrating cutting-edge survey tools, formally committing to short surveys and reading and acting on verbatim comments.  No company is perfect.  No solutions are absolute panaceas. But many aren’t even trying.

The industry needs to start building a bond of trust with respondents.  If bad practice continues (we discuss 5 pitfalls of annoying survey respondents here ) then online quant is doomed.  If we can build bonds of trust the MR industry will be able to continue to ask and analyse the responses to meaningful, tough and insightful questions for years to come.


Contact the Panel Services Team

Reach a 135k+ large Millenial & Gen Z sample, with 400+ data points for profiling. Call us directly, or click below to find out more about what we do.

Tatenda Musesengwa, Client Services Director, 020 7374 0997, tatenda@youthsight.com

Charlotte Woods, Project Executive, 020 7374 0997, Charlotte.Woods@youthsight.com

 

 
Read More FIeldwork Tips

Panel Services

Clients and case studies

Related Posts

A Quick Hello From Our Youth Panel...

12th July 2017

What does the UK's largest specialist youth research panel look like? What makes our panel so unique? The truth is, our panellists know h...

POSTED INFieldwork Tips, Opinion

Fieldwork Tips: The long and short of it – Avoiding the negative effe...

11th November 2015

By Charlotte Woods, Account Manager, Panel Services team Recently we blogged about how to avoid the pitfalls of annoying your surve...

Fieldwork Tips: Avoid the pitfalls of annoying your survey respondents – ...

11th February 2015

Last year we celebrated our 10th year as a specialist youth research agency and panel supplier. Over the years we’ve learned a lot abo...

Fieldwork Tips: The Challenges and Opportunities Offered by Smartphones for...

8th August 2012

Tatenda Musesengwa leads the Panel services team at YouthSight and is responsible for supplying sample to the rest of the market research in...

All panels are equal, but some panels are more equal than others...

28th May 2012

Panel quality is a major issue in the market research industry and rightly so. Debates around data quality, panellist engagement and the imp...

Peanuts and Monkeys – the argument for high quality online research...

15th November 2011

By Ben Marks, Managing Director, OpinionPanel   Online access panels are the workhorse fieldwork mode for the market research...

Fieldwork Tips: Is the traditional survey dead? [Clue: no]...

15th November 2011

By Ben Marks, Managing Director, OpinionPanel The traditional survey is dead.  We’ve reached ‘peak panel’...  That’s what ortho...